For over a decade, Premier League success has been closely tied to possession-based football, with the best teams dominating the ball to control games. However, clubs like Nottingham Forest and Bournemouth are now challenging this paradigm, proving that relinquishing possession can be an effective path to victory.
Possession in football has traditionally been equated with control. Pep Guardiola famously remarked, “To score a goal, you need the ball,” encapsulating the belief that possession is key to dictating play. Yet this season, evidence suggests that teams without the ball may hold the real power. By luring opponents into false confidence and exploiting turnovers, counterattacking teams are thriving.
Nottingham Forest and Bournemouth exemplify this shift. Forest currently sit third in the league despite averaging just 40% possession—the lowest in the division. Bournemouth dominate matches with only 47% possession, while Southampton, despite averaging over 50%, languish at the bottom of the table. This season has seen a disconnect between possession and points, with pressing systems exposing vulnerabilities in possession-heavy strategies.
Statistics highlight this trend: Opta reports record numbers of “high turnovers” (sequences starting within 40 meters of goal) and “fast breaks” (counterattacks initiated from the defensive half). Errors leading to shots have surged from 329 last season to 482 this term, underscoring how pressing and counterattacking are punishing possession-based teams.
Different low-possession teams employ varied approaches. Nottingham Forest defend deep and launch rapid counterattacks into space, as seen in their December victory over Tottenham. Bournemouth deploy a highly organized pressing system that forces errors from opponents—earning them a league-high 40 mistakes this season. Crystal Palace under Oliver Glasner also press aggressively high up the pitch.
These tactics reflect an evolutionary response to possession football’s dominance since Guardiola’s Barcelona revolutionized the game 15 years ago. Bournemouth manager Andoni Iraola noted that football evolves quickly: “What we were talking about 10 years ago is nowadays completely different.”
Even Guardiola’s Manchester City, long considered the epitome of possession football, have struggled this season. City have lost nine league games, including defeats to Forest and Bournemouth. Guardiola acknowledged that opponents are adapting with aggressive man-marking and direct play, forcing his team to rethink their approach. He admitted modern football is shifting away from structured positional play toward more dynamic strategies.
While possession-based football remains dominant in other European leagues—where current leaders Bayern Munich, Inter Milan, PSG, and Barcelona also lead in possession—the Premier League is witnessing a counterattacking renaissance. Whether this trend is temporary or signals a lasting change remains uncertain.
Guardiola insists he will not abandon his principles and may reignite City’s form next season. Similarly, Ange Postecoglou could improve Tottenham if key players remain fit. However, for now, teams like Forest and Bournemouth are proving that relinquishing possession can be just as effective as controlling it—a dangerous game that is reshaping the Premier League landscape.