Liverpool manager Arne Slot endured a disappointing Carabao Cup final as his side fell 2-1 to Newcastle United at Wembley, marking the Magpies’ first major domestic trophy in 70 years. Despite heading into the match as favorites, Liverpool struggled to impose themselves, with Slot making several critical tactical errors that contributed to the defeat. Here are four key mistakes that defined the Reds’ performance:
Slot’s decision to assign during set pieces proved costly. Burn capitalized on this mismatch by heading home Newcastle’s opening goal. Despite the obvious disadvantage, Slot stuck to his zonal marking system and kept Mac Allister on Burn throughout the game, a stubborn choice that could have led to further issues. Slot defended his decision post-match but admitted Burn’s unpredictability made him difficult to handle.
Diogo Jota’s inclusion in the starting lineup was another questionable decision. The Portuguese forward has struggled for form this season, scoring only eight goals in 29 appearances and failing to find the net since January. His lack of confidence was evident during his ineffective 57-minute display. Slot’s reluctance to substitute Jota earlier compounded the problem, as Liverpool’s attack lacked dynamism until Federico Chiesa came off the bench late in the game.
Slot waited too long to introduce impactful substitutes like Federico Chiesa and Harvey Elliott, who entered with just 16 minutes remaining. Chiesa managed to score a consolation goal, but Liverpool needed fresh legs much earlier to challenge Newcastle’s disciplined defense and regain momentum. The delay in making changes left Liverpool chasing the game with insufficient time to turn things around.
Caoimhin Kelleher started in goal for Liverpool, continuing his role as the designated cup goalkeeper. While Kelleher is an excellent backup, Slot’s decision not to field Alisson Becker—widely regarded as one of the best goalkeepers in Premier League history—was surprising given the stakes of a cup final. Alisson had played in the semi-finals and could have provided added security against Newcastle’s aerial threats.
Slot acknowledged that Newcastle outplayed Liverpool by dictating the style of play, focusing on aerial duels and set pieces where they excelled. “If we play ten games like this, they win nine,” Slot admitted after the match. He also lamented his team’s inability to create chances and maintain possession under pressure.
While Liverpool remains 12 points clear at the top of the Premier League table, this defeat—coupled with their Champions League elimination earlier in the week—raises questions about Slot’s decision-making in high-stakes matches. With plenty of time left in the season, Slot will need to address these shortcomings as Liverpool aims for domestic success and redemption after back-to-back setbacks.